Much Award Business

This morning at Worldcon was filled with much business to do with Awards. The results of the Business Meeting deliberations, and the new about the new Campbell pin, have been posted to SF Awards Watch. Here’s a small amount of personal opinion.

Mostly I’m very pleased with what the Business Meeting has done. However, the debate over the removal of the Semiprozine category appeared to involve a lot of odd discussion. Those in favor of the motion continue to assert that they are not trying to remove the category just to stop Locus from winning any more awards. However, when challenged to provide examples of their rationales they were peculiarly unable to do so. Ben Yalow said it was because there are not enough magazines eligible for the category, so was not an honor to be nominated, but in fact there are very many small press fiction magazines that pay contributors and carry advertising that appear eligible. That argument simply doesn’t hold water.

Seth Briedbart went on to complain that some of the magazines that do get nominated for Semiprozine are not worth reading. This is a very old and tired argument, and basically it boils down to “I don’t like the things that get nominated so I will define them as not Hugo-worthy.” Seth specifically mentioned 5th-place finishers, so let us take a quick look at the sort of publications that the proposers of this motion think are so bad they are not worth reading (let alone worthy of a nomination). Last year that was Lady Churchill’s Rosebud Wristlet. In 2006 it was Interzone. In 2005 and 2004 it was Interzone’s (now deceased) Fantasy/Horror sister publication, The Third Alternative. These are not inconsequential magazines. And of course in 2006 Emerald City came fourth in the category. Was it also not worth reading? And if so how come it won a Hugo as a fanzine two years before?

There were no other arguments presented for the proposal. So what does this tell us about people’s motivations? If we are generous it says that people who attend the Business Meeting do not read small press fiction magazines and don’t think that there should be a Hugo for such things. Alternatively the truth of the matter, despite all of the protestations to the contrary, is that the category is being killed to stop Locus from winning it.

A Note On Geography

All of the convention parties are in the Sheraton. It is several blocks walk from the convention center. There is a Hyatt across the road from the convention center with a decent bar in it. Of an evening, most of the fans are in the Sheraton grazing the parties, and most of the pros are in the bar at the Hyatt. I have been in the bar with Chris Roberson, so it is now a proper convention.

Actually the geographic issues are worse than that, because the filk, gaming and anime are in the Sheraton, and the readings are in another hotel (one of the Hyatts, I’m not sure which). And yet we look lost in the vastness of the convention center. I guess there must be a reason for it – such as having to buy function space in the hotels in order to get decent room rates.

Hugo Press Coverage

Chris Barkley in the Denvention 3 press office tells me that National Public Radio is looking to do interviews with Hugo winners after the ceremony on Saturday. This is excellent news.

Meanwhile I am slightly disappointed at the lack of reaction I am seeing to Sam Jordison’s article on the Guardian book blog. Fandom has been complaining for ever that the mainstream media doesn’t care about us, and now we get a preview of the Hugos in a national newspaper and no one says anything. Get on over there and say “thank you”, people, and let The Guardian know that covering science fiction gets them readers.

Worldcon: Day 2

I finally got away from my computer at around 1:00pm and headed off to the convention. I was able to bag a couple of good interviews about future Worldcons – one with Farah Mendlesohn about programming in Montreal, and one with Stephen Boucher about facilities in Melbourne. I need to clean the audio up before I can podcast them, but hopefully they will go live next week. I’m also hoping to talk to Dave McCarty about the innovative ideas the Chicago in 2012 bid has about supporting memberships.

I did a quick tour through the Art Show and found a couple of things worth mentioning. I think that the Raku Ray Guns have been mentioned online before, but now I have seem them in real life and I can confirm that they are every bit as awesome as they look in photos. Elsewhere in the show I was impressed by Myles Pinkney, particularly this picture, which I may just buy a print of.

I was pleased to see that the exhibits area has filled up a bit. Obviously some folks were late arriving. However, the con still looks lost in such a big building.

The “SF Outside of the English-Speaking World” panel went very well, and we could have easily filled another hour with all the stuff there was to talk about. Many more people are now in awe of Finnish fandom.

I was going to be at the Chesley Awards ceremony this evening, except that ASFA has had a few problems and there will not be any awards given out until later in the year. This leaves me at a loose end for the evening. I’m not quite sure what I shall do, but I suspect that the words “Chris Roberson” and “bar” will feature somewhere along the way.

I’m also thinking that I might be able to do live blogging from the Hugos. Stay tuned for more news.

Worldcon: Day 1

It turns out that I adopted the right tactics about Registration. I went back in the afternoon and there was no queue at all for my line. I still haven’t got to the bottom of what went wrong, but it seems clear that the Reg staff made some daft decisions about splitting lines without taking into account which letters of the alphabet were most popular for beginning names. Also they may have been slowed down by lots of people being surprised and/or offended that they were required to present photo ID to attend a Worldcon. It was a graphic demonstration of how far Security Theater has become embedded in the psyche of anyone running an event.

The convention center is huge, and membership is pretty low (I have heard suggestions of 3,500) so the convention looks lost. I would love to be able to stage Finncon here, but Worldcon looks very thinly spread. This isn’t helped by the fact that the Exhibits people don’t appear to have anything much except the standard traveling Worldcon exhibits. The one exception to this is the Technology of Reading exhibit where Colin Hinz has done a magnificent job of providing examples of mimeo technology and printing. The actual mimeograph appears to be in good condition, so I’m very hopeful for Sunday.

My best laid plans of attending Opening Ceremonies were waylaid by getting invited out to dinner by the Locus folks. More of that in a separate post. They also sidetracked me from my intention to attend the Friendly Scandinavians party, though Gary Wolfe made up for that by offering me a sample from his bottle of Akavit, which turned out to be very nice.

Kathryn Cramer has posted photos of Peter and Elizabeth having fun at Summer Camp. It looks like a very good excuse for not being here.

The program is pretty uninspired so I have been spending the morning blogging. This is just as well as it has proved to be a very busy day on SF Awards Watch. And we have the Chesley Awards to come tonight as well.

Registration = FAIL

There are some things about Worldcon that ought to be solved problems. Registration is one of them. Since ConFrancisco in ’93 ever Worldcon committee has been determined to avoid long lines. Except, apparently, Denver. The waiting time appears to be at least half an hour, probably longer. I have better things to do with my life.

So I have been wandering around talking to people. There are lots of people here that I know. And even more people here who know me. I am mastering the art of glancing quickly at people’s badges when they hail me because (I am pleased to note) the names on the badges are nice and large. So there I was talking Frank Wu into coming to the mimeo demo and trying to draw on a stencil (which he has given a provisional “yes” to) when some guy taps me on the shoulder. I blank for a few seconds. “I’m John Scalzi,” he says, “remember me?” *mega blush* I swear last time I saw him he was wearing a tiara and he looked totally different.

I’ve also taken advantage of the time to pop back to the hotel. I’d forgotten to put on a watch, and also I had forgotten all of my rules about hot weather. So I have blistered a toe, and I had forgotten to use Nalo Hopkinson’s secret remedy for sticky thighs. I will now head back out fortified against the heat.

Aussie Party No Beer Shock!

There were some very red faces amongst the Melbourne contingent this evening. The bid parties are being held in function space at the Sheraton, and the hotel won’t let alcohol be served. Of course this meant that that more money could be spent on food, and there was a decent spread put on for all of the uber-SMOFs who are gathered here the day before the con begins. Also spotted in the party were Bob Silverberg, Mike Resnick and David Hartwell, not to mention the only member from Malaysia – Glenda Larke, who I was delighted to get to meet at last. It looks like a Worldcon is underway.

But not for everyone. David might be here, but Kathryn Cramer is not. Apparently this is the last week of Summer Camp, and the junior Hartwells absolutely cannot leave for Denver. Far too much fun is being had. So all those of you who think that an early August Worldcon is good for parents with kids, think again. The middle of the month is apparently better.

Anyway, I have arranged to record a short chat with Stephen Boucher about the fabulous new convention facilities in Melbourne. That will probably happen on Thursday, fingers crossed, so it will be a few more days before I can edit it and get it online.

Meanwhile Geri Sullivan and Glenn Gazer have been enthusing to me about the exhibits that Colin Hinz has brought to go along with the mimeo demo. This is going to be good.

Denver: So Far So Good

The Colorado Convention Center is slap in the middle of Downtown Denver. This is very convenient. Within a couple of blocks walk I have found Starbucks, Subway, Jamba Juice, Bubba Gump’s, Hard Rock Cafe, Johnny Rockets, and whole host of other places to eat and drink. I suspect that the Corner Bakery may become the regular venue for breakfast. I’ve also run into John Picacio and Alan Beatts – carrying a suspicious heavy box; Evil Kevin, Andy and the Pettingers – who reminded me that I have an article in the program book; Peggy Rae and John Sapienza – on their way to sample a nice-looking Italian restaurant; and Alan Stewart – who told me how to find the not-secret-but-well-hidden Australia in 2010 party. I am now going to check out his directions.

Too Many Conventions

Not content with Finncon and Worldcon, I have just signed up for WordCamp, which is a WordPress convention taking place in San Francisco on the 16th. I have to be in The City anyway for SF in SF and I run enough WordPress blogs these days that I really ought to learn a bit more. Keeps me out of mischief, I guess.

Finncon Photos

I have finally managed to get my photos for Finncon online. They’ll make more sense when the con report goes up, but at least they’ll get you started. There are lots of anime costumes, some of them quite spectacular. Also several photos Harald – the Viking restaurant – and of Tampere Cathedral.

Note to John Coulthart – having checked the guide book, it appears that the only painting by Magnus Enckell is the altar fresco (which does indeed include men holding hands, though they are dead). The main fresco is by Hugo Simberg, who also painted the magnificent “Garden of Death”.
Continue reading

Worldcon Update

I’ve now had a chance to go through the Worldcon program in detail. When I said on the questionnaire that I didn’t want to be on any more “electronic fanzines, threat or menace?” panels I figured I was being over-cautious, but I see that they have two of them. I won’t be attending either.

On the awards front I see there is also a Golden Ducks ceremony. That is scheduled against the Sunday Business Meeting, which is where the Melbourne folks will be announcing their GoHs, but the two panels seem to be next door to each other so I may manage to hit bits of both. There is also a Friday panel on the history of the Campbell which I might get along to.

Talking of the Business Meeting, Saturday could be quite busy. In addition to the motions mentioned by Mike Glyer (to kill off the Semiprozine category and add a Graphic Novel category) there should also be a report from the Digital Wilderness Committee that will (finally) put forward proposals for clearing up any doubt as to whether electronic publications are eligible for the Hugos.

The one panel that I definitely want to hit is on Thursday at 4:00pm. It is called “Fandom and SF outside the English-speaking world” and it features Christian Sauvé of Fractal Framboise, Rani Graff from Israel, Alvaro Zinos Amaro from Spain and Sarah Hoyt, who is originally from Portugal. If I get a chance to put in a good word for Finland then I shall do so.

Finncon Report Status

The con report is written, but I need to check some spellings of Finnish names and process the photos before I post it. In the meantime, you can find the filk songs for this year’s Guests of Honor (and some previous years) online here. (Thanks Liisa!)

Worldcon Schedule

It appears to be the fashion for people to post details of what panels they will be on at Worldcon. Goodness only knows why any of you would want to see me in person, except perhaps to confirm for yourselves that I should not be let out in public without a paper bag over my head, but I am involved in some interesting panels and I hope to be doing some interesting journalism during the convention. Here is a brief run down of the plans.
Continue reading

Mr. Dog, He Dead

Finncon is over, I have just come back from the dead dog party, which once again was held at a sauna out in the countryside. The lake water was a bit cold tonight so I didn’t swim much, but the sauna was great and the whisky I brought seemed to go down well.

In the car on the way back to the hotel Charles Vess was telling us about the Totoro Forest Project. Apparently there’s an exhibition coming to the Cartoon Art Museum in San Francisco in September. I hope to get to see it at some point over the winter.

Also we had a very Finnish experience. Just gone midnight we were rolling into Tampere and Marianna said, “let’s take the scenic route”, because of course there was still enough light to do so.

There will be a proper con report later. Hopefully I’ll get it written on the train back to Helsinki tomorrow.

Finncon – In Progress

Hello, I am back at the hotel, footsore but happy. I have survived 5 hours consecutive programming, and am looking forward to my reward – dinner at Harald, the local Viking restaurant. I don’t have much time to blog, and anyway I have been in cosplay and panels all day so I haven’t seen much of what is going on outside of those events. Fortunately for you, Tero has been posting lots of good material. Go ye here for lots of things I need to put on SFAW when I get the time, and other reports as well.

Asian SF – Help!

So today at the sauna I got asked to help with a panel, because the Finns know I am an expert on SF and can talk about anything. Tomorrow I have to fill a 1 hour panel talking about Asian science fiction. I know almost nothing. And so I’m asking you folks. I have emailed David Brin to ask about the Chengdu convention. Any other help would be much appreciated. Thank you.

Finnish ConRunning

This year’s Finncon is taking place in Tampere Talo, which is apparently the largest convention center in the Nordic countries. There will be photos. It is very nice. It is costing the con €40,000 to rent for the weekend. Membership is still free. The money came half in government grants – no individual grant more than €5,000 – and half in advertising sales. Marianna, the con chair, tells me that they had two students of business administration doing fund raising for them as part of a final year project.